Rooted in the heart of Plymouth, Indiana, Farmers Mutual Insurance Company has been built on trust, integrity, and the strength of community since 1872. What began with three men and a promise has grown into a legacy of neighborly support and dependable protection that stands the test of time. Guided by generations of dedicated leaders, including the Ruff family, we’ve proudly evolved with the changing world while keeping our small-town values alive where a handshake, a signature, and your word still mean everything.

Today, Farmers Mutual remains a company owned by its policyholders your needs drive every decision we make. Our agents live and work in the same communities they serve, ready to answer your call when life takes an unexpected turn. From modern coverage solutions to genuine personal care, we’re here to make sure you feel supported, secure, and valued every step of the way. That’s not just good business it’s the Farmers Mutual way.